Monday, June 13, 2011

A fairer NRL draw


Following on from yesterday’s article on how to avoid lopsided matches during the representative rugby league season I have a solution that would give the NRL a fair draw and actually reduce the amount of matches played each year.

Not much has been said recently about player welfare, but when we have a season that starts in February and ends for internationals as late as November, it will come up at some stage again – as it does every year.

Also, we have a situation in the NRL at the moment where a club’s schedule is deciding capriciously year-in, year-out. Some teams you play twice, some once, according to the whims of HQ.

At the moment the NRL Premiership consists of 26 rounds, with each club having two byes. My system contains 22 rounds, plus four weekends for State of Origin and the NRL Cup, as detailed yesterday.

My proposal is to divide the league into two conferences, like so:

Conference A                                               Conference B
North Queensland                                        Manly
Brisbane                                                       Easts
Gold Coast                                                   Souths
Newcastle                                                    Cronulla
Penrith                                                         New Zealand
Parramatta                                                   St George Illawarra
Wests Tigers                                                Canberra
Canterbury                                                   Melbourne

We could name in the Australian and National Conferences, or name them after stars of the past. In short, a team would play the other clubs in their conference home and away (14 games) and the outfits from the other conference one time (8 games) with an even split of home and away games. The conferences would stay the same every year. This would preserve existing rivalries and create new ones.

In short:
Intra conference: (7 x 1 home) + (7 x 1 away) = 14 games
Out of conference: (4 x 1 home) + (4 x 1 away) = 8 games
Total:                                                                   = 22 games

With the aforementioned four Cup weekends, you’d still have 26 rounds of action before the finals. Although, keep the McIntyre System.

So the season would look like this:

Week                          Round
1                             NRL Round 1
2                             NRL Round 2
3                             NRL Round 3
4                             NRL Round 4
5                             NRL Round 5
6                             NRL Round 6
7                             NRL Round 7
8                             NRL Round 8
9                             NRL Round 9
10                          NRL Round 10
11                          Cup Round 1 and State of Origin
12                          NRL Round 11
13                          NRL Round 12
14                          Cup Round 2 and State of Origin
15                          NRL Round 13
16                          NRL Round 14
17                          Cup Semi Finals and State of Origin
18                          NRL Round 15
19                          NRL Round 16
20                          NRL Round 17
21                          NRL Round 18
22                          NRL Round 19
23                          NRL Round 20
24                          NRL Round 21
25                          NRL Round 22
26                          Cup Final – Stand Alone Event
27                          Qualifying Finals
28                          Semi Finals
29                          Prem Finals
30                          Grand Final

All over in less than seven months – plus another comp into the bargain.

Now, there’s something missing … international football! I thought long and hard about that but I am against the midseason Test matches – they are often lop-sided and look crazy in the program, being played before State of Origin.

That’s not to say I’m all for abolishing international rugby league – far from it. I just believe it should be played in its out discreet window after the grand final – that way it has its own presence and you get players picked on form (most often out of grand final winning sides).

I believe in the Four Nations Tournament and would be happy to see it continue in its current format, or expanded to include a Pacific Nations team and France along with the usual three suspects and PNG.

In fact, I feel a whole different article about that coming on … watch this space.

No comments:

Post a Comment