As I wrote yesterday, the FFA has a lot of problems with the A-League. A lot of them will be forgotten on Sunday, when the best football team the competition has seen, Brisbane Roar, host arguably the best club, Central Coast Mariners.
I’ll be doing a bigger preview later on it week, but I see the Roar winning 3-1 to complete a well-deserved league-grand final double and leave the boys from Gosford ruing yet another grand final defeat.
It’s a long way down the track, but if Ange keeps his Brisbane team together they could become the first Australian team to win the Asian Champions League. The way they have played this year has been phenomenal and an amazing advertisement for the world game in this country.
What hasn’t been a great advertisement is a sad-sack league campaign full of midweek games and clubs getting closer to the brink of folding – or in the case of the North Queensland Fury, being killed off.
There is also one gaping, yawning hole in the domestic scene that needs to be filled, ASAP.
That would be the lack of a nationwide, knockout competition, colloquially known as the cup. Every football league and nation worth its salt has one – England’s FA Cup is the only football tournament on the planet – except maybe the UEFA Champions League - that rivals the World Cup for name recognition.
And with the domestic league and the Socceroos restricted to pay TV at the moment, name recognition is something football in Australia sorely needs. That’s not a knock on Fox or the FFA by any stretch, just fact. If you don’t have Foxtel or Austar, you aren’t seeing the game played at the highest level in this country.
Commentators, players and fans are all begging for a knockout competition to run parallel to the A-League.
Even the AFL is planning a knockout competition for the near future. It would be a travesty for the world game here if a rival code were the first to introduce a format that belongs to football.
There are lots of questions about how to get a cup competition up and running in Australia, such as the disparity of the state organisations, sheer geographical distances involved and financial pressures.
I have a naïve, but potentially workable, solution.
Obviously, we’d need a naming rights sponsor and a television deal. Also, I think it’s only fair the FFA help subsidise the travelling costs for the smaller clubs. A cash prize (doesn’t have to be huge, but something) would also be a must. If the FFA are as good at selling football as they need to be, this should be a snap. After all, a new, ground-breaking, unifying competition would be good news at a time the sport is crying out for it.
In the first year, I'd have a 32-team draw - enough for five extra games a season - with the A-League clubs entering the draw in round one. The FFA and state associations can work out the timing, but ideally, it would be in the same window as the A-League, with the final on the weekend between the end of the league and the start of the finals series. That would make it a showpiece event at the time of year where football is not battling cricket or the winter sports for attention.
To cut costs and ensure the state league clubs get to tackle their elite intra-state counterparts, I'd divide the 32 teams into five pools (take a deep breath, it's still a knockout comp): Victoria, NSW/Capital Football, Nthn NSW/Qld, WA/NT and SA.
A diagram version of the draw – based on the Australian A-League sides (No Wellington
Phoenix, they should be playing in the NZ domestic Cup) and the winners/top fives of the assorted state leagues I could find - can be found here. Be sure to right click! It's a bit rough and made from a dodgy excel template generator, but you'll get the picture. You gotta scroll to worksheets 10 and 11 too. Sorry.
In round one, teams would only be able to be drawn against teams from the same pool - that would create the chance of some A-League sides copping each other early, thus opening up the draw for the underdogs. It would also increase the chance of a state league power facing to their intra-state A-League counterparts. For example, Sydney FC v Sydney United might be more meaningful and well-supported than Sydney FC versus a state league team from, say, South Australia, at least in the opening stages.
I'd also have any games involving state league clubs against A-League clubs at suburban stadiums or regional venues to help the gate of the smaller outfit.
The pools would be:
NSW: Sydney FC, Central Coast Mariners (A-League), the top five NSW state league sides and the champions of the Canberra-based Capital Football. (4 games)
Victoria: Melbourne Victory, Melbourne Heart (A-League), the top five Victorian State League clubs and the title holders from Tasmania. (4 games)
Queensland/Nth NSW: Brisbane Roar, Gold Coast United, Newcastle Jets (A-League), the best team in the Northern NSW league and the best four from Queensland. (4 games)
South Australia: Adelaide United and the three best clubs in SA. (2 games)
Western Australia: Perth Glory, two WA teams and one from the Northern Territory. (2 games)
The draw would remain be restricted to the pools for the round of 16, with another in-pool draw. This would be aimed at reducing the travel costs of the smaller clubs and fostering the intra-state rivalries between A-League sides and their state league counterparts. Again, I’d like to see games played at suburban or regional centres, rather than the big grounds.
At the quarter-final stage, the draw would be thrown open with all the teams left standing against each other, same as the semi-finals.
I’d have the semi-finals played as double header at the same ground to a) give the best chance of a full house and magical atmosphere and b) encourage massive media coverage and ease the logistical pressures.
The ground I’d pick would be AAMI Park in Melbourne, which I’d also like to see host the final – Australia’s answer to Wembley, if you will.
The possibilities - and benefits - are obvious.
“Old soccer” would meet “new football” in the one place it matters – on the pitch. Save the quality example of the Melbourne Victory and Melbourne Heart, who will play in the next Mirabella Cup against the Victorian state league clubs, there isn’t a lot of this going on.
Former NSL clubs would get a lifeline back to the elite and a chance to celebrate their proud and vibrant histories in a meaningful fashion.
There could be a live midweek press conference to draw the rounds – imagine people from Melbourne Knights or Sydney United huddled around their TV sets, finding out they’d be playing Melbourne Victory or Sydney FC the following weekend! Or the uproar if Newcastle Jets cop Gold Coast United in round one!
There should be specific weekends – sorry, match days – spliced into the league schedule where these games could be played, a la the FA Cup. In lieu of league games, TV could cover these. Or, once the current deal is up, sell the cup as a different package – I’m sure SBS would snap this up in a heartbeat.
Cup competitions provide the obvious romance of an underdog knocking off a big team, although while this comp is in its infancy I’d have draws decided by 30 minutes each way, then penalties, to save time/expense of replays.
Rubbing shoulders in a competitive situation with the biggest clubs in the land would show lower clubs what it would take to become elite at player, coaching, admin and supporter levels. This in turn could get them ready for a B-League – which I hope comes in the next 10 years - or expansion – which I hope comes when the time is right and all clubs are on a solid footing.
Having A-League clubs playing all their games away - or if drawn against another top-flight side, in a country/regional venue - would take elite football and footballers to places that don’t get a lot of A-League at the moment. And there’s plenty of places that don’t. Ask the potential fans in Canberra. Or Western Sydney. Or Wollongong. Or Geelong. Or Hobart. Or now, sadly, Townsville.
Of course, it would also fulfil one of the requirements for Australia to win another
Asian Champions League spot.
I don’t often go begging for feedback – but I’d like it on this one. Click here to send me your responses and ideas.